Grain Fed vs. Grass Fed Beef: Understanding the Differences
Listen on your favorite podcast platform:
Spotify | Apple Podcasts | YouTube | IHeartRadio | Amazon Music
In this episode of the Foundational Health Podcast, Dr. Kevin Schultz explores the contentious topic of grass fed versus grain fed beef. Is the higher price of grass fed beef justified by its health benefits? Dr. Schultz delves into the nutritional differences, environmental impacts, and economic factors that influence your choice.
Learn about the life cycle of both grass fed and grain fed cattle, the implications of their diets on your health, and why supporting local farmers might be the best decision for you and the planet. Tune in to get all your questions answered and make an informed decision about the beef you consume.
Grass-Fed vs. Grain-Fed Beef: Is It Worth the Cost?
When it comes to buying beef, one of the biggest questions people have is whether grass-fed beef is worth the higher price tag. From both a health and cost perspective, it’s important to understand what you’re getting for your money. Is grass-fed beef truly better for your health? Does it provide enough benefits to justify the extra cost? And beyond personal health, what impact does this choice have on the local economy and the environment?
In this post, I’ll break down the key differences between grass-fed and grain-fed beef, including nutritional value, potential health effects, and the broader implications for sustainability.
The Differences Between Raising Grass-Fed and Grain-Fed Cattle
Raising cattle follows a similar process in the early stages, regardless of whether they are grass-fed or grain-fed. Calves nurse from their mothers and graze on grass and plants for the first several months of life. However, after weaning at around five to eight months, their paths diverge significantly, leading to major differences in their diet, living conditions, and overall health.
Grain-Fed Cattle
After weaning, most conventionally raised cattle are moved to feedlots for "finishing," where they are rapidly fattened on a grain-based diet.
Key points about grain-fed cattle:
Fed primarily corn and soy, often genetically modified and pesticide-treated.
Kept in crowded feedlots, leading to stress, limited movement, and increased disease risk.
Require frequent medical interventions, including:
Vaccinations for respiratory and digestive diseases.
Regular antibiotics to prevent and treat infections.
Steroids and anabolic implants to accelerate weight gain.
Deworming and parasite medications.
Reach market weight faster, making them cheaper to raise and sell.
Not all grain-fed cattle experience extreme feedlot conditions—some small farms use grain for finishing while still prioritizing better animal welfare.
Grass-Fed Cattle
Grass-fed cattle remain on open pastures after weaning, consuming a natural diet of grass and forage.
Key points about grass-fed cattle:
Allowed to graze freely, getting natural exercise and fresh air.
Eat a diet more aligned with their natural needs.
Require fewer (or no) medical interventions due to better overall health.
Take longer to reach market weight, making production more expensive.
Require more land for grazing, contributing to higher costs.
Because of these differences, grass-fed beef is often more expensive but may offer benefits in terms of animal welfare, nutrition, and overall sustainability.
Nutritional Differences Between Grass-Fed and Grain-Fed Beef
Research has shown that grass-fed beef contains higher levels of beneficial nutrients, which impact both the health of the animal and those who consume it. As the saying goes, “We are not just what we eat, but what we eat eats.” This concept becomes clear when examining the nutritional differences between grass-fed and grain-fed beef.
1.) Leaner Meat and Fewer Calories
Grass-fed beef is naturally leaner than grain-fed beef, meaning it contains less fat and fewer calories.
The average American consumes about 66 pounds of beef per year (roughly 3 ounces per day). Switching to grass-fed beef could result in an 18,000-calorie difference annually—equivalent to around six pounds of weight gain or loss per year.
For those who consume more beef daily, the impact on calorie intake and weight management becomes even more significant.
2.) Higher Levels of Key Vitamins and Beneficial Fats
Vitamin Content: Grass-fed beef contains more vitamin A and up to four times more vitamin E than grain-fed beef.
Conjugated Linoleic Acid (CLA): This beneficial fat, found in higher amounts in grass-fed beef, has been shown to aid fat burning and may have cancer-fighting properties.
Phytonutrients: Grass-fed beef from cattle consuming a diverse diet of plants and grasses contains phytonutrients commonly found in fruits and vegetables, such as terpenoids, phenols, carotenoids, and tocopherols.
3.) Omega Fatty Acids and Health Benefits
Omega-3 Content: Grass-fed beef contains up to five times more omega-3 fatty acids than grain-fed beef.
Improved Omega Ratio: Grass-fed beef helps balance the omega-6 to omega-3 ratio, which is essential for reducing inflammation and improving overall health.
Short-Term Health Benefits: A study found that in just four weeks, participants who switched from grain-fed to grass-fed beef experienced a measurable increase in omega-3 levels and a decrease in omega-6s in their blood.
While this discussion focuses on beef, these nutritional principles apply to other animal products as well, such as pasture-raised poultry and eggs, which offer similar benefits over conventionally raised options.
Understanding Omega-6 and Omega-3 Fats
One of the most critical takeaways from this discussion is the importance of balancing omega-6 and omega-3 fatty acids. These essential fats play a crucial role in our body's immune and inflammatory responses, but when they're out of balance, they can contribute to chronic disease and poor health.
The Role of Omega-6 and Omega-3 Fats
Omega-6 fats promote inflammation, which is necessary for healing and immune responses.
Omega-3 fats counterbalance inflammation, ensuring it doesn’t become chronic and harmful.
Our bodies are designed to maintain a 1:1 ratio of omega-6 to omega-3.
The Modern Omega Imbalance
The average American diet contains a staggering 45:1 ratio of omega-6 to omega-3—far from the ideal balance.
This chronic excess of omega-6 leads to persistent inflammation, which is linked to nearly every major disease, including:
Early aging and muscle loss
Osteoporosis and bone weakening
Autoimmune disorders
Increased risk of blood clots, cancer, and heart disease
Brain fog, chronic fatigue, and sleep disturbances
Persistent joint and muscle pain
The Impact of Diet on Inflammation
Many people suffer from chronic pain and inflammation without realizing its root cause. However, those who switch to an anti-inflammatory diet—reducing processed foods and increasing omega-3 intake—often experience dramatic improvements within just 30 days.
Why Are Omega-6 Levels So High?
The primary culprit is processed food, which makes up 70% of the average American’s daily calorie intake. Common sources of excess omega-6 include:
Processed snacks (chips, crackers, cookies)
Fast food and fried foods
Industrial seed oils found in packaged foods
Grain-fed meats, barn-raised poultry, and farmed fish
The Seed Oil Problem
Many processed foods contain high levels of seed oils, which are rich in omega-6 fats. While some claim that seed oils are harmless, the issue isn’t whether they have some health benefits—it’s that we are consuming them in massive excess.
The “Evil Eight” Seed Oils to Avoid
These are the most common sources of excess omega-6 in processed foods:
The Three C’s: Canola, Corn, Cottonseed
The Three S’s: Soy, Sunflower, Safflower
Two Others: Grapeseed, Rice Bran
How to Restore Omega Balance
The ultimate goal is to reduce processed foods and focus on whole, natural foods without ingredient labels, such as:
Fruits and vegetables
Nuts and seeds (in moderation)
Pasture-raised eggs and poultry
100% grass-fed beef and wild-caught fish
While many people are focused on avoiding sugar—rightfully so—it's just as important, if not more, to cut down on omega-6 seed oils. By prioritizing whole foods and reducing processed oils, you can help restore your body’s natural inflammation balance and improve long-term health.
Other Differences Between Grass-Fed vs. Grain-Fed Beef
When comparing grass-fed and grain-fed beef, many people focus only on nutrition, but there are other key differences, including environmental impact, cost, and flavor.
1. Environmental Impact
Grass-fed beef is often the more sustainable choice:
Fewer pesticides: Grass-fed farms typically use little to no pesticides, making them better for human health and the environment.
Improved soil health: These farms use regenerative agriculture practices that promote biodiversity, enrich soil quality, and prevent depletion.
Lower pollution: Grass-fed systems reduce runoff and chemical contamination compared to conventional grain-fed operations.
2. Cost
The higher price tag of grass-fed beef comes down to time and land requirements:
Twice the time to raise: Grass-fed cattle take nearly twice as long to reach market weight compared to grain-fed cattle.
More land needed: Grass-fed cows graze over larger areas, while grain-fed cattle are often confined to feedlots where land is used for growing grain instead.
Fewer government subsidies: Industrial grain-fed operations often receive significant subsidies, reducing costs for producers and consumers.
For many people, cost is the biggest barrier to choosing grass-fed beef, even when they understand the health and environmental benefits.
3. Flavor and Texture Differences
Some people prefer grain-fed beef due to:
Higher fat content: The grain diet leads to more marbling, making the meat more tender.
Sweeter, milder flavor: Grain-fed beef tends to have a richer, buttery taste, whereas grass-fed beef has a leaner, earthier, slightly gamier flavor.
Others, like myself, strongly prefer the taste of grass-fed beef, but for those accustomed to grain-fed beef, it can be an adjustment.
Understanding Meat Labeling: What to Look For
When buying meat, poultry, or fish, food labels can be misleading. Many large-scale food producers use deceptive labeling to make their products appear healthier or more natural than they really are. Understanding these terms is essential for making informed choices and ensuring you get the highest quality, nutrient-dense foods.
The Truth About “Free Range” Chicken and Eggs
Grocery store “free range” doesn’t always mean what you think. A chicken raised in a crowded barn, never seeing sunlight, can still legally be labeled as free range.
True free-range chickens are those raised outdoors, with access to pasture, natural sunlight, and their intended diet.
Local farms often raise genuinely free-range chickens but may not be aware of labeling laws. If you're buying from a small farm, ask how the animals are raised instead of relying solely on labels.
Farmed vs. Wild-Caught Fish
Wild-caught fish eat their natural diet, making them more nutritious and free from harmful additives.
Farmed fish are often fed corn and soy pellets—far from their natural diet—leading to lower nutritional value and higher levels of omega-6 fats.
Beef Labeling: What Grass-Fed Really Means
Many people assume that grass-fed beef means the cattle ate grass their entire lives. Unfortunately, due to USDA labeling laws and industry lobbying, this isn’t always true.
“Grass-fed” simply means the cattle ate grass at some point in their lives.
Most grass-fed cattle are “grain-finished”, meaning they were fed GMO grains in the last few months before slaughter, negating the health benefits of a grass diet.
For the best quality, look for “100% grass-fed” or “grass-finished” beef—these cattle eat grass their entire lives.
The Best Choice: Local, Trusted Farms
Whenever possible, buy directly from local farmers who prioritize animal welfare and natural diets. Many small farms produce high-quality meat but don’t always follow complex labeling laws, meaning their products may be superior to what you find in grocery stores, even if the labels don’t reflect it.
By understanding these labels and supporting ethical, sustainable farming, you can ensure you're consuming healthier, more nutrient-dense meat while avoiding deceptive marketing tactics.
Local Farms Offering Grass-Fed Beef and More in the Chippewa Valley, WI
If you're ready to start incorporating more grass-fed beef and other high-quality, local meats into your diet, here are some fantastic farms in the Chippewa Valley of Wisconsin that I highly recommend. These farms offer pasture-raised meats and other wonderful products, all while supporting small, local, and sustainable farming practices.
1. Siverling Centennial Farms (Bloomer, WI)
Siverling Centennial Farms offers more than just grass-fed beef—they provide a variety of meats raised in a sustainable way. While they do feed small amounts of high-quality grains during the winter months, they produce an exceptional product.
2. Farm Sweet Farm (Cadott, WI)
Known for their 100% grass-fed beef and pasture-raised chickens and eggs, Farm Sweet Farm is a local gem. They also run OneFest, a Christian music festival in Cadott.
Discount: Mention the Foundational Health Podcast to get $10 off a smaller beef order or a free roast when you buy 25 pounds or more.
3. Against The Grain Pastures (Eau Claire, WI)
Another great local option, Against The Grain Pastures offers 100% grass-fed beef and practices sustainable farming.
4. St. Brigid's Meadows (Coon Valley, WI)
Located near La Crosse, St. Brigid’s Meadows offers 100% grass-fed beef, grass-finished lamb, pasture-raised pork, and pasture-raised chickens and eggs. They’re famous for their delicious brats and even offer delivery to select areas.
5. WhiteTail Organics (Colfax, WI)
WhiteTail Organics raises grass-fed beef, pasture-raised poultry, and pork. This farm prioritizes organic farming practices to ensure top-quality, GMO-free meats.
6. Together Farms (Mondovi, WI)
A USDA Organic certified farm, Together Farms offers 100% grass-fed beef, lamb, and pastured pork. They also feature a farm store with amazing products from other local farms and host a burger night that runs from spring to fall.
Special Offer: Free local home delivery with orders over $179 and 5% off if you subscribe. You can also order online at togetherfarms.com and use the Code "Health 10" for 10% off (for a limited time).
Inspirational & Educational Takeaways
As we wrap up today's discussion on grass-fed vs. grain-fed beef, here are some key takeaways and inspirational tips to keep in mind:
Success is simple habits performed daily over time.
It’s all about consistency—small, daily actions add up and create lasting results.Take a cooler everywhere.
This tip, introduced by my wife, is a game-changer. By packing a cooler with healthy foods—like cold burgers and hard-boiled eggs—we ensure that we always have nutritious options on the go. I find these foods are just as convenient as protein bars or shakes!The 90/10 Rule.
Aim to get 90% of your daily calories from whole, high-quality foods. Start where you are, and work your way toward this goal gradually.The truth about beef studies.
Many studies linking beef to heart disease, cancer, and high cholesterol are flawed because they focus on conventionally raised and grain-fed beef. If you’re eating grass-fed beef—raised as nature intended—it’s an entirely different story. Studies show that 100% grass-fed beef has significant nutritional benefits, and it’s a healthier choice.Be a leader in health.
Your choices, whether in food, exercise, or even your words, set an example. Lead by example, especially in today’s world, where many are making poor health decisions.
Episode Sources:
https://www.mdpi.com/2304-8158/11/5/646
https://www.mdpi.com/2304-8158/12/19/3547
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19502506/
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9259595/
https://farm.ewg.org/cropinsurance.php
https://www.iarc.who.int/featured-news/media-centre-iarc-news-glyphosate/
https://jneuroinflammation.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12974-024-03290-6
https://pubs.rsc.org/en/content/articlehtml/2022/em/d1em00454a